Real vs Fan-Made Artist Merch — How to Tell the Difference
Three categories: official licensed (XO, OVO, Cactus Jack), fan-made (us and similar), and counterfeit (sold AS official without licensing). They aren’t the same. Knowing which is which decides whether you’re buying real cotton or a markup.
📑 Jump to a section ↓
Three Categories — Spelled Out Plain
Most “real vs fake” debates lump fan-made and counterfeit together. They aren’t the same:
- Official licensed: the artist signed off, gets royalties. Sold by XO, OVO, Cactus Jack, the artist’s own store. Highest price tier.
- Fan-made: independent brands designing era-graphic interpretations without using official logos. Legal, clearly labeled, mid-tier price (us, others).
- Counterfeit: reproduction of the official logo, sold as official, no royalties to artist. Illegal. Always avoid.
The buying decision is between the first two. The third should never be a choice.
4 Things That Actually Differ ↓
Licensing — the main price gap
Official merch pays the artist 15-30% of retail in royalties. Fan-made merch doesn’t. Same cotton, different paperwork.
Cotton blanks are often identical
Fan-made brands and official drops both pull from Gildan, Bella+Canvas, AS Colour, Champion, etc. The blank you’re buying is frequently the same garment. Print and tag are what change.
Counterfeit ≠ fan-made
Counterfeit reproduces the official logo and sells AS official. That’s illegal and harms the artist. Fan-made merch uses original era-graphic interpretations without licensed marks. Legal, honest, and clearly labeled.
How to spot counterfeit
Off-color logo proportions, generic dropship sites with no “about” page, prices that don’t match the brand’s official tier. Read the about page; legit fan-made brands say “fan-made” plainly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is buying fan-made disrespectful to the artist?
Reasonable question. Fan-made pieces don’t pay royalties, so technically the artist gets nothing from each fan-made sale. But streaming gives them something; merchandise is a small slice of artist revenue overall. If you can afford official, buy official. If you can’t, fan-made is honest middle ground (and infinitely better than counterfeit).
Is 6ix Merchandise fan-made or counterfeit?
Fan-made. We design original era-graphic interpretations of artist catalogs (Drake’s eras, Weeknd’s eras, etc.) without reproducing licensed logos like the OVO owl or XO logo. We say so plainly on every page.
How can I be sure a brand is fan-made, not counterfeit?
Read the about page. Legit fan-made brands say “fan-made” or “not officially licensed.” Counterfeit sites avoid that language. If a site is unclear about licensing AND charges official-tier prices, assume counterfeit.
Final Word
Three categories, two honest options. Pick official if budget supports it; pick fan-made if it doesn’t. Skip counterfeit always.
Shop full catalog at 6ix Merchandise
All Toronto-designed: heavyweight French terry hoodies and heavyweight cotton tees. Free shipping on every order, worldwide.
Read next: more guides
Essential reading from across the 6ix Merchandise editorial:
Buying & care guides
Per-artist buyer’s guides